Is An Automatic Safer Than A Manual?

    Posted by Ben Davidson about 1 years ago

    Some people view and automatic as an easier car to drive, while others view it as a glorified go-kart. For some who don't have the necessary skills, the automatic takes a lot of the stress out of the process of driving. But, in terms of overall safety, is an automatic transmission safer than a manual? Let's find out.

    The Impact On The Driver

    The first thing to state about a automatic vehicle is that the stress of the operation of the vehicle means that because there's a lot less to do in terms of the driving, it becomes an easier task. Some people find driving a manual stressful because it doesn't come naturally. There is a handy article on that highlights the causes of driver stress and cures for this stress. But, put simply, if there is less to do in the vehicle, it makes the act of driving much easier. By the same token, driving a vehicle with minimal function could mean that the driver's attention is going to waiver. As a result, there could be an influx of car accidents, and the potential for distracted driving is going to be much higher. has an article on why texting and driving was behind a church bus crash, after 13 senior parishioners were killed by a young driver texting behind the wheel. And as driving an automatic seems to be much easier, as soon as you begin to know the roads, this could be a dangerous situation for any automatic driver.

    The Cost

    Comparing the costs of a manual transmission to an automatic, right away, an automatic is going to cost more upfront, but also the fuel cost is going to be more too. Because the car automatically changes gears for you, it naturally burns through more fuel. So you will get more miles per gallon out of a manual then you will an automatic. Depending on how much you drive, this is going to have to factor into your overall costs. You will be filling up the tank more in an automatic.

    The Control

    Speak to some people who have gone from a manual to an automatic, and they will tell you they will never go back to a manual because their life is so much easier. But for drivers who have had experience with both types of transmission will tell you that a manual gearbox is safer because they have more control of the vehicle. An automatic transmission is going to change gears automatically, and therefore is making a certain amount of guesswork of the best gear in any situation. And while automatic transmissions have become more sophisticated in recent years, it doesn't equate to what you can do with any given situation. You will be able to react better in an unusual situation, like a slippery road, or a collision up ahead.

    But, from a safety standpoint, both manual and automatic transmissions have no distinct advantage over the other. The only thing to really consider is the cost of the vehicle. If you can afford an automatic, and you don't enjoy the process of driving, this would be a better option. But if you like the idea of grinding gears and clutch control on a hill, then a manual is going to be the preferred option. But as far as safety is concerned, they are both equally matched.


    Latest Articles

    See All
    • Getting Your Car Ready For a Spring Road Trip
      Getting Your Car Ready For a Spring Road Trip

      March 20, 2019 - Who can resist all of the fun journeys across the United States? Before you get to enjoy the trip, however, you’ll need to make sure your car is in the right condition. We take a look at a few preparation options for your vehicle below.

    • 3 Tricks for Reducing Driving Test Stress
      3 Tricks for Reducing Driving Test Stress

      March 14, 2019 - No one really wants to be the person who only passes their driving test on the fifth attempt, and yet that does happen to people, and not so rarely, either....

    • Repairing Your BMW
      Repairing Your BMW

      March 14, 2019 - The type of service you need depends on your car; the make of it, how old it is, how long it has been since your last service and how many miles you have driven.

    • Is It Time To Get A New Car?
      Is It Time To Get A New Car?

      March 7, 2019 - Like all good things, the relationship with your current vehicle needs to come to an end. For most people, it’s not a question of if, but when, and it’s not always easy to make the decision to part with your car and invest in a new one.

    • Responsibility On And Off The Road In Terms Of Yourself, Other People, And Your Car
      Responsibility On And Off The Road In Terms Of You...

      February 27, 2019 - There’s a lot you can do to be more responsible as a car owner whether you’re on or off the road. If you want to protect yourself, other people on the road (or in your vehicle), and your car itself then these helpful suggestions should help you to ta

    • Diving Down The Repair Hole: Car Fixes You Should Never Do!
      Diving Down The Repair Hole: Car Fixes You Should ...

      February 20, 2019 - It's always tempting for us to try and save a bit of money by doing car repairs ourselves. After all, it's not that hard, is it? We know our car pretty well, so surely we can at least do the majority of these fixes?

    • Buy New, Buy Used, Or Lease: Pros & Cons
      Buy New, Buy Used, Or Lease: Pros & Cons

      February 15, 2019 - So, let’s simplify things. Below, we’ve looked at the pros and cons of each of the three options, so you can see - at a glance - which might be the most suitable for you.

    • Cutting Down Car Maintenance Costs Like A Boss
      Cutting Down Car Maintenance Costs Like A Boss

      February 15, 2019 - Here, we’ll talk about how you can cut down your car maintenance costs like a boss. Whether you have a little run around or a more expensive sports car, the below tips will help you to cut back on unnecessary payments.

    • 5 Ways To Spend Less On Auto Repairs
      5 Ways To Spend Less On Auto Repairs

      February 15, 2019 - A single repair can land you in financial trouble if you don’t have the money to cover it, but you can’t really avoid it. If the car is broken and you need it, you’ll have to get it fixed whether you can afford it or not. That might mean borrowing mo

    • What To Do If Your Child Is In A Car Accident
      What To Do If Your Child Is In A Car Accident

      February 15, 2019 - This is a worst-case scenario, and we’ve knocked on wood that you or your child will never have to experience this throughout their whole driving career. But well-wishes and hopes don’t help much when the event has just taken place. Instead, you want

    Share This!